Volume 1, Issue 1, 2007    
       
  The Effects of Involvement on a Website:  A Case Study of a Service Provider    
       
 

Gary Kaskowitz, Moravian College, GKaskowitz@moravian.edu

   
       
 

Abstract

This research looks at whether a local, service-based professional can successfully use the internet to recruit clients and increase the purchase intent of prospects. In particular, this study looked at whether an interactive personality or knowledge assessment tool would increase desire for sales information about a service more than a free information product would. In addition, the purchase intent was measured for these respondents. It was found that an interactive assessment created a higher proportion of prospects registering for an opt-in marketing campaign than did the free information product. It was also found that respondents who participated in an interactive survey expressed higher purchase intent and perceived pricing than did respondents who received a free e-book. These results suggest that interactive assessments may be a meaningful alternative for on-line marketers looking to increase opt-in and purchase intent.

Introduction

Interactive marketers are constantly looking for ways to increase permission to send e-mails as well as increasing the likelihood of purchase among prospects. Interactive marketers often provide information to prospects as a way to garner permission to send future e-mails to the prospect (i.e., "opting-in"). One highly effective way that interactive marketers have used to is to offer a free information product (e.g., an e-book) to the prospect in return for permission to send e-mails about the firm’s product or service, with the hope that these consumers will purchase the product or service at that time or in the future.

It is generally thought that the more involvement a prospect has with a purchase decision, the more likely he/she is to review information associated with the product or service. This increased level of involvement can lead to an increased liking of the product or service, as well as an increased probability of purchase. This study investigated these issues by exploring whether an interactive assessment would garner more goodwill and purchase intent for an internet-based service provider than would a free information product.

Background

While many businesses now use the internet for marketing purposes, this trend is not as prevalent with small service-based professionals. Many small businesses in general, and service providers in particular, are very proficient at their respective specialty (e.g., accounting, physical therapist, counseling, coaching) yet not many are well-versed in business and marketing skills. It has been shown that many small and medium enterprises do not use strategic marketing planning when they conduct their business (Lancaster and Waddelow 1998). Many small, local businesses see their competitive advantage in serving a niche market while trying to maintain current customers (O'Donnell et al. 2002), and don’t necessarily have a cohesive strategic plan for attaining new customers. Still, an integrated internet component in a small service firms’ marketing strategy can be very advantageous to the firm (Banta 2004).

Compounding this problem is the fact that consumers today are both developing more resistance to any types of persuasion attempts (Friestad and Wright 1994) as well as becoming more wary of any electronic communications from business in general (Godin 1999; MacPherson 2001). A main concern for many marketers today is how to build trust with an increasingly wary consuming public (Lewis and Bridger 2001). In addition, the regulatory environment is making the sending of e-mails for commercial purposes more restrictive (Johnson 2004). To overcome these issues, it has been argued that when marketing on the internet, it is better for potential customers to identify themselves to the business and agree to have marketing information sent to them (opting-in) (D'Souza 2003; Godin 1999; Tezinde et al. 2002).

As many on-line marketers are aware, a key method to create interest and opt-in is by offering free information, such as e-books, about the topic in which the sold product is a part. However, reading e-books is essentially a passive activity, and while providing information is a very effective marketing technique for establishing trust and credibility, there could come a point of diminishing returns when many, if not most, on-line marketers choose this route.

While free e-books serve the role of providing information to people browsing the internet, many studies show that the internet is used as an entertainment vehicle as well (Barwise et al. 2002). It is becoming increasingly important for businesses to be able to build trust and differentiate themselves from each other, especially on the internet, if they don’t want to be perceived as a commodity (Pine and Gilmore 1999). Marketing on the internet needs to be seen as a compelling on-line experience if a business is to appear different from its competitors. Creating compelling experiences have been shown to be positively correlated with fun, recreational and experiential uses of the web (Novak et al. 2000) as well as by having a highly interactive website (Ghose and Dou 1998) or providing enjoyable information (Eighmey 1997).

It has been demonstrated that the more involved a person is with a website, the more positive his/her experience is likely to be. This can be as simple as an involved consumer paying more attention to the content of a website (Webster 1988) to a person taking on a role within the website that enhances his/her experience (Edwards and Ferle 2003).

In addition, past research has shown that the more involvement a person has with a product, the more likely he/she will be to express higher purchase intent. This effect has been demonstrated in both off-line (Singh et al. 2000) and on-line (Raney et al. 2003) media where the effects of infomercials and on-line mini-movies, respectively, were studied. However, these studies have looked at involvement and purchase intent based upon a person watching a long message. The author has not found any research conducted on interactive exercises and purchase intent.

Study Introduction

This study looked at methods for increasing opt-in to future e-mail marketing messages from a small service provider, as well as increasing the stated purchase intent of the service by the respondent. A traditional method on-line marketers use to garner opt-in (and purchase) is to offer an incentive to the prospect, traditionally some form of e-book or other free electronic publication. This method is very desirable in that the cost of delivery is free and the entire delivery and subscription process can be handled automatically. Yet, it is believed that while free information is an effective incentive, another type of incentive might be even more effective at inducing opt-in among prospects.

Consumers tend to use the internet as a source of information as well as entertainment (Barwise et al. 2002; McKeown 2002; Siegel 2004). Free information, such as e-books, help fulfill the information need consumers seek when browsing the internet. However, the downloading and/or reading of an information product are relatively passive events and may not be enough incentive to induce consumers to trust a commercial website or purchase a product from the site. In particular, how can a business help build enough trust with a consumer to induce him/her to give the marketer permission to market? It is believed that the more entertaining and experiential the website is, the more likely it is that the consumer will view the site and the provider in a favorable light (Bharati and Chaudhury 2004; Hill and Gardner 1987; Ko et al. 2005; McKeown 2002). It is also fairly well-accepted that the more highly involved a consumer is with a purchase, the more favorably they are likely to view the experience and purchase decision (Bharati and Chaudhury 2004; Lewis and Bridger 2001; Pine and Gilmore 1999; Prahalad and Ramaswamy 2004).

Based on this idea, this study compares the marketing effectiveness of these two well-known types of internet behavior (i.e., seeking of information compared to being entertained). Two unique incentives are compared for their ability to increase opt-in to permission marketing, as well as any possible influence on the perceptions of the business and likelihood to purchase from the service provider. The first incentive tested is an information product (free e-book) compared against the alternative incentive of a free personality or knowledge assessment offered to the prospect. The personality assessment was chosen to be an interactive, experiential exercise for the consumer.

The human desire for involvement and self-discovery would suggest that an assessment incentive improves opt-in rates for permission marketing and perceptions of the business compared to a free e-book incentive. It was hypothesized that a more interactive technique might better establish trust and credibility thereby increasing the desire to receive further information from the on-line marketer. One of the main purposes of this study was to explore whether a short, interactive survey would garner more opt-ins to receive information than would a free information product.

The study also explored whether respondents who choose to take the interactive assessment would state a higher likelihood of purchasing the service than would those respondents who chose the free e-book. Because the internet lends itself very easily to truly interactive exercises, this study also explored the effect of an interactive exercise on purchase intent as compared to a more passive exercise (i.e., reading a book).

Methods

Sample
This experiment compared two websites for a personal services coach to see which one would produce the higher opt-in rate. A pilot study was conducted with participants selected from an e-mail list of the general population who had agreed to receive promotional and study-related e-mails. A sample of 5000 e-mail addresses was obtained for this study. Of these 5000 e-mails sent, 437 were undeliverable and 12 people asked to be removed from the list. 81 respondents completed the study over a three-day period. While the response rate for the pilot study was very low, it is not believed that there was any non-response bias, for several reasons. First, the respondents were told that in a welcome e-mail that they were being asked to participate in an academic research project about their perceptions of a web page. There was no discussion about the experimental conditions being studied, and any respondents who chose to not participate would be choosing not to do so based solely on their desire to not review a website for a research project. This in and of itself did not have anything to do with the experiment, and so any conclusions drawn from the actual respondents regarding the experimental conditions could be seen as “real” in that the actual purpose of the study was masked from the entire sample (both respondents and non-respondents). Second, at the end of the survey, the respondents were allowed to express their opinions of the website they had reviewed as well as any general comments. From reading these responses, it was seen that the focus was on the web page itself, and not to do with the experimental conditions. Third, any bias that might be introduced in this study would be from the fact that some people chose to not participate in the research. However, as this study was concerned with how to increase opt-in and purchase intent for people who do read these type of websites (service providers), non-respondents would not be a part of this population anyway. Because respondents who did choose to participate in this study were randomly assigned to treatment groups, it is believed that there is no selection threat present.

The original sample of 81 respondents associated with the pilot study did yield some interesting directional findings in all areas under investigation. However, there was not enough power associated with this sample to draw statistically significant findings on the dependent variables of interest (e.g., purchase intent). In order to increase the power of this study, the original sample was supplemented with a second, convenience, sample of undergraduate students from two marketing principles classes (n=47) for a total of 128 completed surveys. The study procedures were identical for both samples.

There was some concern that there might be a difference in the responses of the two samples (original and student supplement) on the dependent variables due to the fact that the two groups were demographically different. For the original sample, the average age of respondents was between thirty-five and forty-five, the majority was married, and they had an average household income of $45,000. The supplemental student sample had an average age between eighteen and twenty-four, with the majority being single and from middle to upper-middle class familes. In addition, the majority of respondents in the original sample worked full-time, whereas the student sample was mostly comprised of full-time students. Because of these obvious demographic differences between the two samples, each sample was analyzed separately on all of the experimental variables before they were aggregated. This analysis showed that there were no statistical differences across the two groups on the variables of interest (i.e., likelihood of opting-in, attitudes towards coach and website, propensity to purchase the coaching product, and amount likely to spend on the coaching product), indicating no readily apparent selection threat to internal validity. Therefore the two samples were combined for analysis.

Procedure
The procedure for this study was identical for both sample groups. Upon agreeing to participate in the study, respondents were first directed to an introductory web page where they were told that they were being asked to evaluate the website of a personal services provider. The respondents were told to explore the website at their leisure, and to feel free to follow any links that they came across. They were further instructed that when they were finished reviewing the website they would be taken to the survey. As compensation for completing the experiment, the respondents were offered a free e-book on success principles that had previously been sold on-line. This introductory web page was the same for all study participants.

After reading this introductory web page, the respondents were randomly directed to one of two websites to test the experimental conditions. The two websites were identical in nature and presentation, except for the independent variable of interest (the offering of a free e-book vs. free assessment). The website was designed to look like it was offering the services of a personal services coach offering a “Perfect Life” program (created by Thomas Leonard, one of the founders of modern life and business coaching). At the bottom of both web pages, the respondents were asked if they would give permission to receive further information from this coach (the opt-in portion). As an inducement to provide their name and e-mail address for future correspondence (the opt-in portion of the experiment), the respondents were offered either a free e-book explaining more about attaining a perfect life, or the opportunity to take a free assessment on “The 15 Human Conditions,” depending on which website they had been randomly redirected to. There was no directive to download the book or take the assessment, and these options were fully integrated into their respective web pages.

At the bottom of the web pages, the respondents were asked to take a survey. When they clicked on this link the respondents were directed to the survey portion of the website where they were asked questions about the website in general, attitudes towards the “coach,” as well as several pricing and purchase intent questions based upon a Van Westendorp pricing model (MarketVision 2003). General comments were then solicited and demographics were collected. The survey for both experimental conditions was identical, with the exception of the e-book group being asked about e-books and the assessment group being asked about assessments for that portion of the survey (e.g., “Did you download the free e-book?” vs. “Did you take the free assessment?”). The researcher developed all websites used in this study, which were identical in nature except for the variable of interest.

Study Results

54 respondents were randomly directed to the website offering the free e-book incentive and 74 were randomly directed to the site offering the opportunity to take the free assessment. As part of their review of the website, the respondents were offered either the chance to take the assessment or receive the e-book as an incentive to give permission to the “coach” to send future e-mails. A significantly greater proportion of respondents opted-in by choosing to take the assessment, than did those who downloaded the free e-book, with more than twice as many respondents taking the assessment compared to downloading the e-book (28% compared to 13%, respectively; z = 2.084, p < .05).

Respondents who elected to receive the free e-book (i.e., opted in) were then compared to respondents who did not elect to receive the free e-book for the first website, and respondents who took the free assessment (i.e., opted in) were compared to respondents who did not take the free assessment (for the second website). Several questions were asked about the perceived professionalism of the coach and website, as well as about interest in receiving further communication from the coach. In all cases, those respondents who opted-in (whether by selecting an e-book or assessment) gave higher scores for their perceptions and willingness to receive follow-up e-mails than those who did not opt-in. Respondents who opted-in by taking the free e-book were significantly more likely to be “interested in receiving follow-up e-mails” from the coach informing them about products and services than were those respondents who did not download the free e-book (6.86 vs. 4.40 on a 10-point mean agreement scale). The same finding was true for those respondents who chose to take the interactive assessment compared to those who did not take the assessment (5.81 vs. 4.28 on a 10-point mean agreement scale). For this same group, (took assessment compared to did not take assessment), there were also significant findings for the statements, “The website appeared to be professional in layout,” and “I would be interested in receiving follow-up e-mails from this coach.”

Those respondents who opted-in by receiving the free e-book or taking the assessment were then asked their perceptions of the product.  Respondents who took the assessment gave higher favorability scores (on a 10-point scale) on all dimensions compared to respondents who downloaded the free e-book.  However, while these results appear interesting from a directional perspective, none of these findings were statistically significant (most likely due to the very small sample of respondents who actually downloaded the free e-book).



The last part of this study looked at the purchase intent and pricing estimates for those who opted-in compared to those who did not.  The first set of comparisons was for those who selected the free e-book compared to those who did not select the free e-book.  Due to the small sample size of respondents who actually chose to download and opt-in via the free e-book (n = 7), none of these findings were statistically significant.  Nonetheless, there were some interesting directional findings in that those respondents who did choose to download the free e-book stated a higher likelihood of purchasing the program than did those respondents who chose to not download the free e-book.  Another interesting finding was that the average floor price for this program for both of these groups was the same, i.e., both groups of respondents (e-book downloads or non-e-book downloads) valued this product the same.

When comparing those respondents who took the free assessment against those who did not take the free assessment, statistically significant findings were observed for purchase intent.  When asked to set the lowest price they would expect to pay for a product where they would question the quality if it were any lower (floor price) and then state the likelihood of buying the product at this price, those respondents who took the assessment stated an average 59% probability of buying the product at their self-selected floor price compared to those respondents who did not take the assessment (with an average 40% probability of buying the service at their average self-selected floor price).  A very interesting finding was observed in that those respondents who took the assessment stated a lower average floor price for the service ($73) than did those respondents who did not take the assessment ($164).  However, the average price for both of these groups was higher than the average stated floor price for both e-book groups ($36).

Discussion

The results of this study appear quite encouraging for on-line businesses wishing to use interactive assessments.  It can be seen that the percentage of people who elected to opt-in by taking the assessment was over twice the percentage of people who opted-in with the free e-book (28% vs. 13%).  Respondents who opted-in were more likely to be favorably predisposed to receiving follow-up communications from the coach than those who did not opt-in, regardless of the opt-in incentive.   This suggests that the interactive assessment tool creates a higher involvement and liking of the coach/service and therefore leads to more prospects for future communication from the marketer.   

In addition, those respondents who chose the assessment were more likely to be interested in reading additional e-mails from this coach as well as believing that the website was professional in nature, whereas those respondents who received the e-book were not as strong on this measure.  This is most likely mitigated by the fact that such a small number of respondents actually chose to download the free e-book, because there does appear to be directional evidence that the e-book opt-ins were more favorable towards the coach and website than the e-book non-opt-ins.  This suggests that while involvement of any kind is a good thing for the on-line service provider to include in his/her website, the more interactive nature of the assessment appears to be a somewhat stronger effect.

Directional evidence also suggests that the interactive assessment received higher scores for it being interesting, informative, and fun compared to the e-book.  Considering that e-books typically cost more time and money to create than an assessment, these results would appear to bode well for using interactive assessments as an opt-in tool in terms of generating interest in the service provider and the service being offered.

Of special importance to the on-line services marketer is the propensity to purchase something as well as how much a prospect would be willing to pay for the service.  Here, several interesting results and implications can be found.  Regardless of involvement type (i.e., downloading free e-book or taking interactive assessment), those respondents who were more involved with the website consistently reported a higher purchase intent than did those respondents who were not as involved with the website.  When asked to set a floor price and then report  purchase intent based upon the floor price, those respondents who took the interactive survey reported purchase intent that was 19% higher on average than those respondents who did not take the interactive survey. 

When asked about the minimum price a respondent would be willing to pay for this service, two interesting findings appear.  First, the specified minimum price was higher on average for the assessment option group than for the e-book option group ($138 compared to $36 averages, respectively).  When the two groups were divided into the opt-ins and the non-opt-ins, the same trend held (i.e., the assessment-takers reported a higher minimum price than the e-book takers, and the non-assessment takers reported a higher minimum price than the non-e-book takers).  This implies that, overall; the interactive exercise option (assessments) is associated with higher purchase intent and pricing than the free information (e-books).   With information becoming the “currency” of the internet, perhaps people are beginning to devalue e-books when compared to other involvement options.  Namely, it is entirely possible that the prevalence of information in general, and e-books in particular, makes people expect this as a tables-stake of a website, and do not lend its presence any additional value other than what is customarily expected.

Second, and perhaps somewhat counter intuitively, it was found that for those respondents who had the option of taking the assessment, those respondents who took the assessment were more likely to purchase the product, but at a lower price ($164 for the non-assessment takers compared to $73 for the assessment takers).  This can be compared against the e-book option group where the average minimum price the respondents would pay was the same for both the e-book takers and the non-e-book takers.  There are several interesting implications that can be drawn from this.  It might be suggested that taking the interactive assessment somehow de-values the worth of the program in the minds of the prospects.  However, it should also be noted that even the lower average minimum price of $73 for the assessment takers was higher than the average of both e-book option groups ($36).  It might also be the case that there are some demographic and/or psychographic differences among the assessment-takers and the assessment-non-takers, although a preliminary analysis of the collected demographics did not reveal this.  Perhaps, the increased involvement on the part of the assessment-takers leads them to be more price-sensitive, as many consumers expect internet-based businesses to be more price-competitive (Verma and Varma 2003). It could also be the case that people who are more involved with a website are spending more time focusing on the content and are more favorably inclined to evaluate the website (Hill and Gardner 1987; Ko et al. 2005). If this is happening, it could be the case that assessment takers are giving a more reasoned (and perhaps more accurate) answer than the non-assessment takers. In short, this is an interesting question for future research.

Limitations, Future Research, and Marketing Implications

While this study lends support to the notion that an interactive assessment can increase opt-ins, purchase intent and minimum purchase price for a service provider marketing on-line, some limitations should be noted. First, while it appears clear that the interactive assessment led to more opt-ins than the information product, many of the findings for the e-book takers are limited in power due to the small number of respondents who actually downloaded the free e-book. Based on the directional results obtained here, a larger number of people exposed to the e-book option would increase the power of these tests and most likely show significant involvement features such as liking and credibility.

Also, as most market researchers will verify, stated purchase intent does not necessarily lead to actual purchase (e.g., (Newberry et al. 2003). Therefore, the purchase intent numbers shown here would most likely represent the upper-bound of what would actually be sold.

This study also suggests several areas of future research that would be interesting to explore. For example, are there demographic and/or psychographic differences among people who choose to become more involved with a website than those who choose not to? Does increased involvement with a website lend itself to more price-sensitivity on the part of the browser? What would the actual purchase behavior be in this type of scenario (as compared to stated purchase intent)? Would the findings of this study translate to other types of services and products that are sold on the internet, and if so, which type of product appears to benefit the most from interactive involvement? And lastly, does the nature and duration of the interactive involvement have any bearing upon the questions that were addressed in this study?

As can be seen, this research does have practical and theoretical implications for the on-line marketer. The results of this study would suggest that on-line service providers consider using a more interactive involvement technique, such as an assessment, either in addition to or in lieu of free information.

References
 

Banta (2004), "Developing effective multi-channel marketing strategies," in Banta Corporation White Papers. Menasha WI.

 

Barwise, Patrick, Anita Elberse, and Kathy Hammond (2002), "Marketing and the internet," in Handbook of Marketing, Barton A. Weitz and Robin Wensley, Eds. London: Sage.

 

Bharati, Pratyush and Abhijit Chaudhury (2004), "Using choiceboards to create business value," Communications of the ACM, 47 (12), 77-81.

 

D'Souza, Sean (2003), "The psychological power of opting in," in The defining moment reports: Psychotactics.

 

Edwards, Steven M. and Carrie La Ferle (2003), "Role-Taking:  Enhancing the online experience," Journal of Current Issues and Research in Advertising, 25 (2), 45-56.

 

Eighmey, John (1997), "Profiling user responses to commercial web sites," Journal of Advertising Research, 37 (3), 59-66.

 

Friestad, Marian and Peter Wright (1994), "The persuasion knowledge model:  How people cope with persuasion attempts," Journal of Consumer Research, 21, 1-31.

 

Ghose, Sanjoy and Wenyu Dou (1998), "Interactive functions and their impacts on the appeal of internet presence sites," Journal of Advertising Research, 38 (2), 29-44.

 

Godin, Seth (1999), Permission Marketing:  Turning strangers into friends, and friends into customers. New York: Simon & Schuster.

 

Hill, Ronald P. and Meryl P. Gardner (1987), "The buying process:  Effects of and on consumer mood states," Advances in Consumer Research, 14 (1), 408-11.

 

Johnson, Peter A. (2004), "Preserving the promise of the e-mail marketplace:  An economic assessment of the proposed Federal DO-NOT-E-Mail Registry," in The Direct Marketing Association White Papers. New York.

 

Ko, Hanjun, Chang-Hoan Cho, and Marilyn S. Roberts (2005), "Internet uses and gratifications: A structural equation model of interactive advertising," Journal of Advertising, 54 (2), 57-70.

 

Lancaster, Geoff and Ian Waddelow (1998), "An Empirical Investigation into the Process of Strategic Marketing Planing in SMEs:  Its Attendant Problems, and Proposals Towards a New Practical Paradigm," Journal of Marketing Management (14), 853-78.

 

Lewis, David and Darren Bridger (2001), The soul of the new consumer. London: Nicholas Brealey Publishing.

 

MacPherson, Kim (2001), Permission-Based E-Mail Marketing That Works! Chicago: Dearborn Financial Publishing, Inc.

 

MarketVision (2003), "Van Westendorp:  Price Sensitivity Meter," MarketVision Research (Ed.).

 

McKeown, Max J. (2002), Why they don't buy:  The science of selling online. London: Pearson Education Limited.

 

Newberry, C. Robert, Bruce R. Klemz, and Christo Boshoff (2003), "Managerial implications of predicting purchase behavior from purchase intentions:  a retail patronage case study," Journal of Services Marketing, 17 (6/7), 12.

 

Novak, Thomas P., Donna L. Hoffman, and Yiu-Fai Yung (2000), "Measuring the customer experience in online environments:  A structural modeling approach," Marketing Science, 19 (1), 22-42.

 

O'Donnell, Aodheen, Audrey Gilmore, David Carson, and Darryl Cummins (2002), "Competitive advantage in small to medium-sized enterprises," Journal of Strategic Marketing, 10, 205-23.

 

Pine, B. Joseph and James H. Gilmore (1999), The experience Economy. Boston: Harvard Business School Press.

 

Prahalad, C. K. and Venkat Ramaswamy (2004), The future of competition:  Co-creating value with customers. Boston: Harvard Business School Press.

 

Raney, Arthur A., Laura M. Arpan, Kartik Pashupati, and Dale A. Brill (2003), "At the movies, on the web:  An investigation of the effects of entertaining and interactive web content on site and brand evaluations," Journal of Interactive Marketing, 17 (4), 16.

 

Siegel, Carolyn (2004), Internet marketing:  foundations and applications. New York: Houghton Mifflin Company.

 

Singh, Mandeep, Siva K. Balasubramanian, and Goutam Chakraborty (2000), "A comparative analysis of three communication formats:  advertising, infomercial, and direct experience," Journal of Advertising, 29 (4), 17.

 

Tezinde, Tito, Brett Smith, and Jamie Murphy (2002), "Getting permission:  Exploring factors affecting permission marketing," Journal of Interactive Marketing, 16 (4), 28-37.

 

Verma, D.P.S. and Gaytri Varma (2003), "On-line Pricing:  Concept, Methods and Current Practices," Journal of Services Research, 3 (1), 135-55.

 

Webster, Cynthia (1988), "The importance consumers place on professional services," The journal of Services Marketing, 2 (1), 59-70.
 

   
       
  Return to top.    
 
| Home | Contact UsEditorial Board | Current Issue | Submission |
 
 
 
© Copyright 2006, Scientific Journals International.  All Rights Reserved.